Only just received them so won't do 5 stars until I wear them a bit more. This is my 8th pair of Keen shoes in the past 13 years and my 3rd in the Targhee line. I have been very satisfied with the fit and finish of Keen products, so much so that they are the only brand I will trust to buy without first trying them on. I've tried Merrill and Timberland for hiking and they just weren't right for me. Every pair purchased has fit perfectly as long as you follow the size recommendations. I wear an 8.5 US mens shoe and have a somewhat wide foot. I use the Targhee for Spring to Fall hiking as they are light weight and somewhat breathable. They are waterproof so they aren't as cool on my feet as the mesh versions of Keen hikers but I prefer the dryness when hiking through streams. They are study and, I feel, provide a solid and stable connection to the terrain no matter what it brings. I'm also a fan of the Keen "toe protect zone" which adds a covering of hard rubber over the toes to keep them safe when you stub them on the trail (not the same as steel toe or composite toe which they do offer, I have a pair of Keen composite toe work boots that have saved my toes a few times). I live in the Cuyahoga Valley National Park region and we have rocks, streams, a river you may have heard of, mud and gravel trails and the Keens perform admirably. I highly recommend but, with anything, personal preference is key so make sure they are right for you.--- UPDATE ---So, after 3 years of use, I've decided to upgrade these to 5 Stars. As you can see from the picture, they've held up exceedingly well. I wore these shoes during a 2 week trip to Norway where we did a fair bit of rough terrain hiking and they never once failed. I can't recommend these shoes enough!