I received these 11-11 1/2 mens boots just before Christmas. I usually wear a size 10 4E so I went one size up since a wide size was not an option. They are a bit large, but that's better than tight. The arrival was earlier than originally projected.I live in Minnesota and have worn these boots daily in snow, slush and bitter cold. So far they have made it through multiple 1/2 mile walks in the woods. They do keep my feet warm and dry.I dropped one star to 4 stars because;1- the sole became stiff and I had to add an insole cushion.2-They are also NOT non-slip as advertised. They do slip on icy streets.3- The shoelace hooks were too tight when the laces became wet and swelled. I spread the hooks a little and that worked fine.Other than these minor issues I am satisfied so far considering the extremely low price for winter boots. Will have to see if they hold up over time.I live in an area of the country where snow is rare. However, when we do get snow my porch seems to act as a snow magnet. The snow is usually twice or three times as deep as the actually snow fall itself. I wind up having to fight the get the door open and used to always wind up with wet socks and feet.These boots worked great. I was able to shovel and made a path with no snow getting into the boot itself. And, these are actually comfortable enough that I can wear them often; especially if it rains and I don't want to destroy my nice shoes.The 'fur' lining is nice too.They are nice and sterdyCame apart in two monthsToe wore within first couple of days at work and quickly became no longer waterproof.I wear these boots everyday. They are warm and fit great. Very pleased with this bootsThey are used for snow and daily wear.Para mí, que tengo diabetes, esta bota es excelente en comodidad.